In a competitive work environment, it’s natural to want to showcase your skills and contributions. However, when managers engage in “one-upping” each other—constantly trying to outshine or override their peers—it creates more harm than good.
One major downside is the erosion of trust and teamwork. Managers should operate as a cohesive leadership team, setting the tone for collaboration across the organization. If one manager consistently undercuts or overshadows another, it fosters resentment, weakens relationships, and creates a toxic culture of rivalry instead of shared success.
Additionally, one-upping damages credibility. While it may seem like a way to demonstrate expertise, it often comes across as insecurity or arrogance. Employees and senior leaders can recognize when someone is more focused on personal wins than collective progress. Over time, this behavior can backfire, making the “one-upper” seem less like a capable leader and more like someone who prioritizes ego over effectiveness.
It also stifles innovation and problem-solving. When managers compete rather than collaborate, they may withhold valuable insights, dismiss others’ ideas, or prioritize their own agenda over what’s best for the business. This not only slows progress but can also lead to poor decision-making when different perspectives aren’t genuinely considered.
Ultimately, the best leaders recognize that success isn’t a zero-sum game. Instead of trying to outdo a fellow manager, effective leadership comes from mutual respect, open dialogue, and the ability to elevate the entire team. By shifting from competition to collaboration, managers can create a healthier, more productive workplace that benefits everyone—including themselves.
“Teamwork is the ability to work together toward a common vision. It is the fuel that allows common people to attain uncommon results.”
– Andrew Carnegie
Header image by Mart Production/Pexels.
